Supplemental pay is additional compensation given to employees on top of their base salary. This type of pay, which usually amounts to a small percentage of an employee's regular salary, is designed to reward performance, motivate employees, and incentivize certain behaviors or actions. It is seen as an important element in modern compensation packages since it can be used to recognize excellence and provide additional benefits for employees such as overtime pay.
In this post, we'll explore the meaning and implications of supplemental pay, explore the most common forms of supplemental pay, and discuss the consideration and implementation of a supplemental pay programs.
There are different types of supplemental pay. Let's go through some of the most common forms of supplemental pay:
Bonuses are typically one-time payments given to an employee in recognition of exemplary performance or for completing a certain task. Bonuses are usually awarded on top of an employee's regular salary and may be offered as either a lump sum or as a percentage of the base salary.
It is important to note that bonuses differ from other kinds of supplemental pay, such as commissions and overtime pay, in that they are not required for every job or automatically paid out at specific intervals. Instead, bonuses are awarded based on individual or team performance, and can be used to motivate employees to achieve specific goals. Bonuses can also help employers differentiate their compensation packages from others in the industry and reward employees with incentives beyond their normal wages.
Commissions are supplemental pay that is based on an employee’s individual performance and the amount of sales or services they provide. Commissions are typically a percentage of the total sale price, but can also be a flat fee depending on the situation. For example, a real estate agent might earn a commission on each house they sell in addition to their base salary. Commission payments are often seen as incentives for employees to work harder and reach higher levels of sales or service.
Commissions differ from bonuses in that they are usually tied directly to an individual’s performance or sales numbers rather than being awarded solely based on overall performance or completing certain tasks. Additionally, commissions may be paid out more frequently than bonuses, as they often depend on the number of sales an employee makes over any given period. This can create a closer connection between an employee’s effort and their financial compensation, which can help motivate employees to perform better and make more sales.
Overtime pay is a type of supplemental pay given to employees who work additional hours beyond their regular shift. Overtime pay is usually calculated as a rate of time-and-a-half or double the employee’s regular wage, though it may also be paid as an hourly rate depending on the situation.
Unlike bonuses, commissions, and other forms of supplemental pay, overtime pay is required by law in most countries and employers must adhere to established regulations for paying overtime. Overtime pay differs from other types of supplemental pay in that it is not typically based on performance or sales numbers but rather on the amount of hours worked. It is designed to provide additional compensation to employees for the extra effort they put in beyond their normal working hours, and serves as an incentive for them to stay longer and work harder. Furthermore, overtime pay can help employers retain talented workers who may otherwise seek higher wages elsewhere due to a lack of sufficient compensation from their current job.
Profit sharing is a form of supplemental pay offered to employees that ties their financial compensation to the overall success of the company. This type of pay is usually offered in the form of an annual bonus based on either the company's profits or its return on investment (ROI). Profit sharing can also involve additional benefits such as stock options and 401(k) contributions, though these are not always included.
Unlike other forms of supplemental pay, such as bonuses, commissions, and overtime pay, profit sharing is typically only offered at certain times throughout the year when the company’s performance metrics have been met. This can help motivate employees to work harder with an incentive to increase their own financial gain depending on how successful the company has been in achieving its goals or targets. Additionally, by tying an employee’s income to the success of the company they work for, it can help create a sense of loyalty and responsibility among staff members.
Profit sharing differs from other types of supplemental pay in that it is not necessarily based on individual performance or sales numbers but rather on overall success and performance metrics for the entire organization. Furthermore, while bonuses and commissions may be paid out more frequently, profit sharing is typically awarded annually alongside regular salaries at specific intervals throughout the year.
Stock options are a form of supplemental pay that gives employees the right to purchase company shares at a predetermined price for a set period of time. This type of pay is commonly offered as part of an employee's compensation package, especially when the company is looking to attract and retain talented staff members.
Stock options give employees the chance to benefit from potential increases in share values over a longer term. By offering this type of pay, employers can help motivate staff members while also increasing their own shareholder value over time. Furthermore, stock options can provide employees with added security since they are not dependent on their individual performance or sales numbers but rather on the long-term success of the company as a whole.
Shift differentials are a form of supplemental pay offered to employees for working outside their standard hours or during periods that require additional staffing. This type of pay is typically based on the difficulty and responsibility associated with the shift, as well as any potential hazards or special conditions. For example, if an employee works a night shift, they may receive higher compensation than those working regular hours due to the extra effort and risk associated with working when most other people are asleep.
Shift differentials differ from other types of supplemental pay such as bonuses, commissions, overtime pay, and profit sharing in that they are not necessarily tied to performance or sales numbers but rather on the difficulty and responsibility associated with working certain shifts outside of normal hours. Furthermore, unlike bonuses or commissions, shift differentials may be offered more regularly to employees depending on their specific circumstances without being tied to overall organizational success.
Shift differentials can provide employees with a sense of job security since they are often compensated for additional work regardless of whether the company is making money or not. Additionally, this type of pay can serve as an incentive for employees who may be willing to work unusual hours when others cannot due to its potentially higher rate of compensation compared to other types of supplemental pay.
Incentive pay is a type of supplemental pay that rewards employees for achieving predetermined goals or performance metrics. This type of pay incentivizes employees to work harder to reach their goals and can help motivate them to strive for excellence in their daily tasks. Unlike other types of supplemental pay such as bonuses, commissions, overtime pay, or profit sharing, incentive pay is typically based on individual performance rather than overall organizational success.
Incentive pay often comes in the form of cash bonuses, gift cards, or other non-cash rewards that are offered after employees have achieved predetermined objectives. This type of compensation can help provide added motivation for staff members by giving them an opportunity to receive additional rewards if they meet certain criteria or surpass expectations. Additionally, incentive pay can be used as a way for employers to build loyalty and encourage staff retention since it ties financial reward directly to the achievement of successful performance metrics.
Unlike other types of supplemental pay such as bonuses or commissions which may be paid out more frequently throughout the year, incentive pay typically only comes into effect once an employee has completed a specific goal or task successfully. This makes it more targeted and focused on the specific actions and achievements of individual employees rather than just overall organizational success. Furthermore, since incentive pay is linked directly to an employee's performance it serves as an effective way to motivate them towards higher levels of productivity in order to gain additional rewards and recognition.
Skill-based pay is a type of supplemental pay that rewards employees for acquiring new skills and expanding their knowledge base. This type of pay is typically based on the number and complexity of the skills acquired, as well as the employee's performance with those skills. Unlike other forms of supplemental pay such as bonuses, commissions, overtime pay, and profit sharing, skill-based pay directly ties financial reward to the acquisition and mastery of certain skills.
Skill-based pay can provide employees with an incentive to develop new abilities and acquire more specialized knowledge by offering them compensation for doing so. It also encourages professional development since it provides financial reward not only for mastering a skill but for applying it in productive ways to help benefit the organization as a whole. Skill-based pay may also be used to recognize outstanding performance or reward employees who take initiative when it comes to furthering their education or training in order to acquire new competencies.
Unlike other forms of supplemental pay which may be tied more closely to organizational success, skill-based pay is often determined more independently based on individual accomplishment and progress. The criteria used to determine how much of this type of compensation should be given out can vary from company to company but generally involves some form of assessment or review process that establishes whether or not an employee has achieved certain milestones in terms of skill acquisition and application. Furthermore, unlike other forms of compensation like bonuses or commissions which are typically paid out periodically throughout the year, skill-based pay tends to be much more focused on long term success since it rewards employees for their overall dedication towards developing new qualities over time rather than providing immediate gratification for short term tasks.
This list is not exhaustive. Each of these categories have sub-categories and there are plenty of other types of supplemental pay (i.e. severance pay, holiday pay, on-call pay, and more).
Some types of supplemental pay may be limited or restricted for certain employee types, depending on your company's operating environment. Labor departments and governmental tax bodies monitor supplemental pay for misuse. Often, there are strict rules about how much extra money people can receive as supplemental pay versus base earnings. It's important to familiarize yourself with the rules and regulations in your industry and locality before implementing any supplemental pay programs.
The idea that any employee is purely motivated by money or that they can be "coin-operated" is an oversimplified and outdated view of what drives employees to work hard. There are a variety of other factors that also contribute to employee engagement and performance in the workplace. Factors such as job satisfaction, recognition, respect, trust, career growth potential, and having meaningful relationships with coworkers can all be just as important as pay when it comes to keeping employees motivated and engaged.
That said, there is a direct tie between compensation and things like employee retention, employee productivity, and other key factors of work. Supplemental pay plans such as bonuses and commissions can set you apart from other employers. As an employee seeking the best roles and opportunities, there are clear benefits to supplemental pay as well.
Supplemental pay is often seen as a reward for stellar performance and can be an effective way to motivate employees to strive for excellence. It is a great way to show employee appreciation and recognition while also providing them with additional financial compensation that can make a real difference in their lives. Studies have shown that the best performing employees are highly motivated when there is the potential of earning additional income from their hard work, and supplemental pay offers just that. People who receive supplemental pay for doing outstanding work feel valued, respected, and rewarded by their employers. This sense of accomplishment and recognition enhances morale, motivation, and loyalty among employees which in turn leads to higher overall performance across the organization.
In many roles, supplemental pay programs can more effectively connect work to individual or company goals than regular base pay. In addition, supplemental pay can provide a surprise or delight moment, giving employees extra incentive for exceptional effort.
Supplemental pay programs provide many benefits to employers, as they can help attract and retain top talent, increase employee engagement, and boost productivity. By offering supplemental pay, employers are able to reward their employees for outstanding performance or exemplary attendance. This incentivizes employees to exceed expectations and motivates them to stay with the company longer. Additionally, employers can use supplemental pay programs as a way to differentiate themselves from competitors when recruiting by offering more attractive compensation packages.
Supplemental pay also allows employers to recognize and reward specific skills that employees demonstrate on the job. For example, an employer might offer additional compensation for employees who have special talents or abilities that are not always required but contribute significantly to the overall success of the company. This type of incentive encourages employees to develop new skills or gain certifications that enhance their value as an employee while at the same time providing a financial motivation for them to continue learning and improving.
Finally, providing supplemental pay is often less costly than raising base salaries since it does not require a long-term commitment or commit resources across the entire organization. Employers can tailor their supplemental pay program in order to focus on rewarding key performance indicators while limiting overhead costs associated with wage increases. As such, supplemental pay programs are an effective way for employers to foster a culture of recognition and reward without overspending on wages.
Overall, employers should strive to provide employees with a compensation package that includes not only monetary rewards but also non-monetary benefits such as recognition and respect. By creating an environment where employees feel valued and appreciated for their work they will be more likely to stay productive and engaged in their roles which will ultimately lead to greater organizational success.
When offering supplemental pay to employees, employers must ensure that they are in compliance with all applicable labor laws and regulations. Depending on the country or state, there may be different rules governing the payment of additional wages or bonuses beyond an employee’s regular salary. In some jurisdictions, employers are legally obligated to pay overtime for hours worked in excess of a certain amount per week or month. Additionally, employers must take into account any collective bargaining agreements that may be in effect as these often contain provisions related to extra wages and bonuses.
In the United States, federal law requires employers to comply with the Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA) when it comes to paying workers for additional hours worked. This law sets minimum wage standards as well as requirements for when overtime wages must be paid. The FLSA also has specific requirements regarding bonus payments such as how they should be calculated and distributed among employees. Employers should consult their legal counsel or human resources knowledge experts if they have questions regarding the payment of supplemental income in order to ensure compliance with all applicable laws.
Additionally, companies should consider taking steps to prevent discrimination when distributing supplemental pay among its employees. Before making payments, employers should review whether certain groups of workers are being unfairly excluded from receiving additional compensation due to factors such as gender or race. Employers should strive to be fair and equitable when determining who will receive bonus payments in order to maintain a positive work environment free from discrimination and favoritism.
By understanding the relevant labor laws and regulations pertaining to supplemental pay, employers can make sure they are providing their employees with fair and equitable compensation while avoiding potential legal issues down the line.
Assuming you understand the different types of supplemental pay at your disposal and legal aspects related to that program, you can begin designing a supplemental pay program. Start with these questions:
This is highly dependent on the type of organization and the type of program you're trying to implement, but in general you will want to consider the following stakeholders:
Depending on the scope of the program, it's important to get the appropriate group of leaders and managers in the room when beginning to design a supplemental pay program. Make sure that this group accurately represents the employee base the program will theoretically benefit.
Outside of the right leaders/managers, maybe the most important role in program design is held in finance and accounting. New programs can have impacts on budgets, forecasting, and cash flow amongst other areas. Clearly communicating the type of supplemental pay, the objective of that pay, and the frequency and quantity of pay will help the Finance or Accounting professionals determine the overall financial impact of the program before you get very far in design.
It is important to include human resources personnel in the design of a new supplemental pay program because they will know the rules and laws that must be followed when giving extra money to employees. They can help make sure that everyone gets treated fairly and no one is discriminated against. They can also give a holistic perspective on compensation across different teams and functions. Human Resources will provide an integral role in both design and communication of supplemental pay programs.
Legal counsel, whether in-house or external, should be consulted on any new supplemental pay program as well. Similar to HR, legal teams will be familiar with rules and regulations around certain types of pay. They can also ensure that any communication to employees can be framed appropriately and won't subject the organization to some undue liability or risk.
Are the overarching objectives of the program short or long-term? Do they deal with fixed or variable supplemental compensation? Are these rewards individual or group based compensation? These are important questions to consider.
It may be easier to define the objective of the supplemental pay program in a few steps.
Supplemental pay programs are often only one part of a potential solution for an overarching objective. Ensuring everyone is clear on the main objective, abstracted from a comp program, is an important point of alignment. Here are some sample objectives that may resonate for your organization:
It is important to decide how much money you will spend on the supplemental pay program before designing or telling people about it. That way, you make sure that there is enough money in the budget to delivery supplemental pay to employees if they meet the criteria. It's quite risky to have any mention or communication of the program until a firm budget is approved.
Example: The organization will allocate 10% of the total compensation budget for the supplemental pay program. This 10% should be distributed evenly based on the size of the department/team and will be paid out as quarterly discretionary bonuses for teams that complete measurable stretch objectives (as defined in the quarterly OKR process). Bonuses align exceptional team effort pursuant to company objectives with a team monetary reward.
A clear and concise description for a supplemental pay program is important for communication because it establishes a shared understanding of the objectives, expected outcomes, and responsibilities associated with the program. Without an effective description, employees may be confused about their rights and obligations in receiving supplemental pay, while employers may find themselves in violation of labor laws or exposed to legal action. Keep it short and sweet. Imagine a manager communicating it in less than a minute to an existing or new employee. It should include some aspects of the budget and objective of the program.
Example: At New Co., we believe that when everyone in the organization is working together towards a common objective, great things can be accomplished. To encourage collective teams to strive for the quarterly 'stretch goals' and to reward them for doing so, we have implemented a supplemental pay program. On a quarterly basis, team bonuses will be delivered to teams that complete their stretch goals. The leadership team will celebrate these accomplishments publicly and bonuses will be provided to each team member. The program will provide incentive pay to teams who are able to measurably achieve all of their pre-defined stretch goals.
When creating a new supplemental pay program, it is important to define who is eligible for the additional compensation. By clearly defining the employee base that will be receiving supplemental pay, organizations can ensure fairness and equity in their compensation systems while avoiding potential legal issues or complaints. Additionally, this helps to set expectations among employees and managers regarding who will receive these payments.
Defining who is eligible for supplemental pay should include considerations such as job title or level, years of service with the company, performance evaluations, and any other factors deemed relevant by management. For example, an organization may decide that only employees at certain levels are eligible for bonus payments based on their performance ratings over a given period of time. This would help ensure that those performing at higher levels are appropriately rewarded while also providing an incentive for others to strive towards meeting similar standards of excellence.
This is key. When creating a supplemental pay program, it is important to develop the final criteria that will determine which employees will receive the supplemental pay and which won't. This criteria should be objective and quantifiable. Determining the criteria at the beginning of the program can help you avoid any emotional decisions when it comes time to make payments.
When defining a supplemental pay program, there are several types of payments and structures of payments that may be relevant. Supplemental pay can take the form of bonuses, commissions, stock options, incentive programs, awards or recognition, or even salary increases. Depending on the organization’s goals and preferences for providing incentives to employees, management should define the structure of payments to ensure that they align with their objectives. Additionally, it is important to consider how employees will be able to access or receive these payments. This could include direct deposit into employee accounts or physical checks mailed out on a specific date... even cash payments handed over in person. It is also important to note any expectations from the organization related to tax liability and other financial considerations when determining the amount of supplemental pay.
Depending on the type of supplemental pay, there are rules and regulations for how that pay could and should be delivered. It's important to familiarize yourself with these rules before launching a program.
The method of delivery and timing for supplemental pay is important because it should be fair, equitable and transparent. Generally, payment should come as efficiently as possible after payouts have been determined. Keeping the reward close to the effort or achievement helps maintain the connection between the two and reinforce the appropriate rewards moving forward.
Many programs fall short of the initial objective due to lack of appropriate communication. Here are a few places to consider infusing communication related to supplemental pay programs:
The employee handbook (or digital equivalent) should be changed to include information about supplemental pay programs. It's a great way to ensure that you don't miss the communication for new hires. It's also a great reference for those that want to review aspects of the program(s).
Depending on the supplemental pay, it may be important to adjust the language in employment contracts to match the new program. Especially with things like holiday, overtime, or risk pay, language in the contract can create clarity from the start of employment.
When you pay employees extra money, it is important that their payroll records (and the company's records) indicate the pay appropriately. Often times, this is an additional touch point for the employee and should be well thought out.
It is important to tell managers about new supplemental pay programs. They are often the first line or response for questions around pay, so they should be familiar with the aspects of the program.
Any kind of all-company forum, which may include company-wide meetings, newsletters, or other communications, should be considered as an avenue for announcing new or changing supplemental pay programs. Even employees that are not involved in the program can benefit from knowing about it's existence and intent.
Supplemental pay is an important part of any compensation package, providing additional incentive and motivation for employees. It can take the form of bonuses, commissions, stock options, incentives programs and more. When considering how to implement supplemental pay into your organization’s strategy it is essential to consider various factors such as payment structure and delivery method in order to ensure fairness and transparency. With a well thought out plan that considers all angles of implementing supplemental pay you will have taken one step closer towards creating successful reward initiatives within your company.
Don't just take our word for it. There is a tremendous amount of scholarly research available on the subject and the efficacy of various program types. Here are a few of note, which may be worth scanning as you determine potential programs.
"Share Capitalism and Worker Wellbeing"
The article discusses the effects that employee ownership compensation, like stock options and profit sharing, can have on worker well-being.
The focus of this paper is to analyze the impact of shared capitalism compensation systems on various employee outcomes. These compensation systems are designed to connect employees' pay with their company's performance.
"Discretionary Bonuses and Turnover"
A signaling model is presented in this paper to examine how turnovers are impacted by discretionary bonuses and wage increases.
"The Trouble with Stock Options"
This article discusses the problems with using stock options as a form of employee compensation and looks at the effectiveness of using stock options to incentivize employees.
"Does Group-Based Incentive Pay Lead to Higher Productivity?"
This research covers the effectiveness of group-based incentive pay in a complex production environment with a strong emphasis on teamwork. The analysis uses difference-in-difference estimation to examine how this pay structure affects individual accountability.
.png){kind=small}
The rich text element allows you to create and format headings, paragraphs, blockquotes, images, and video all in one place instead of having to add and format them individually. Just double-click and easily create content.
A rich text element can be used with static or dynamic content. For static content, just drop it into any page and begin editing. For dynamic content, add a rich text field to any collection and then connect a rich text element to that field in the settings panel. Voila!
Headings, paragraphs, blockquotes, figures, images, and figure captions can all be styled after a class is added to the rich text element using the "When inside of" nested selector system.
.png){kind=small}
